Synthetic Short Futures Explained – Futures Options

Best Binary Options Brokers 2020:
  • Binarium
    Binarium

    The Best Binary Options Broker 2020!
    Perfect Choice For Beginners!
    Free Demo Account!
    Free Trading Education!
    Get Your Sing-Up Bonus Now!

  • Binomo
    Binomo

    Only For Experienced Traders!

Futures vs Options

Differences Between Futures and Options

In this article, we will discuss the importance of futures and options and the role they play in the functioning of the derivatives market.

The derivatives market is the financial market for derivative instruments that derive their value from an underlying value of the asset. The contracts categorized under derivatives are:

  • Forwards Contract
  • Futures Contract
  • Options
  • Swaps

Futures contracts are agreements for trading an underlying asset on a future date at a pre-determined price. These are standardized contracts traded on an exchange allowing investors to buy and sell them.

Options contracts, on the other hand, are also standardized contracts permitting investors to trade an underlying asset at a pre-decided price and date (expiry date for options). There are 2 types of options: Call Options and Put Options which will be discussed in detail.

Future vs Option Contract Infographics

Let’s see the top differences between futures vs options contract.

Similarities

There are a number of similarities which exist between these contract which keeps the basics intact:

  • Both are exchange-traded derivatives traded on the stock exchanges around the world
  • Daily settlement takes place for both contracts
  • Both contracts are standardized with a margin account applicable.
  • The underlying asset governing these contracts is financial products such as currencies, commodities, bonds, stocks, etc.

Differences

  1. A futures contract is an agreement binding on the counterparties for buying and selling of financial security at a predetermined price at a specific date in the future. On the other hand, an options contract allows the investor the right but not the obligation to exercise buying or selling of a financial instrument on or before the date of expiry.
  2. Since the futures contract is binding on the parties, the contract has to be honoured on the pre-decided date and the buyer is locked into the contract. Subsequently, an option contract provides just the option but no obligation for buying or selling the security.
  3. For securing a futures contract, apart from the commission amount paid no advance payments are considered as compared to an options contract which makes it essential to make a premium payment. This is done for the purpose of locking the commitment made by the parties.
  4. The execution of the futures contract can only be done on the pre-decided date and as per the conditions which have been mentioned. Options contract requires the performance to be done at any time prior to the date of expiry.
  5. A futures contract can have no limits amounts of profits/losses to the counterparties whereas options contract have unlimited profits with a cap on the number of losses.
  6. No factor of time decay is important in futures contract since the contract is definitely going to be executed. Whether an option contract will be executed will be much clearer while coming closer to the date of expiry, thus making time value of money an important factor. The premium amount paid also considers this factor while calculations.
  7. The fee associated with futures trading is easier to understand since most of the fees remain constant and include commissions on the trade, exchange fees, and brokerage. Other expenses pertaining to margin calls are also involved which also does not change much.

In options trading, the options are either trading at a premium or a discount offered by the seller of the option. These can significantly vary depending on the volatility of the underlying asset and are never fixed. Higher premiums are usually tied to more volatile markets and even assets that are priced less expensive can see the premiums rise when the markets head into a period of uncertainty.

Futures vs Options Comparison Table

Basis of Comparison Futures Options
Meaning Agreement binding the counterparties to buy and sell a financial instrument at a predetermined price and a specific date in the future. A contract allowing the investors the right to buy or sell an instrument at a pre-decided price. It is to be executed on or before the date of expiry.
Level of Risk High Restricted to the amount of premium paid.
Buyer’s Obligation Full obligation to execute the contract There is no obligation
Seller’s Obligation Complete obligation If the buyer chooses then the seller will have to abide by it.
Payment in Advance No advance payment to be made except commission Paid in the form of premium which is a small percentage of the entire amount.
Extent of Gain/Loss No Restriction Unlimited Profits but limited loss
Date of Execution On the pre-decided date as per contract Any point of time before the date of expiry.
Time Value of Money Not Considered Relied heavily upon

Conclusion

As discussed above, both are derivatives contracts having its customization as per the requirements of the counterparties. Options contract can reduce the number of losses unlike futures contract but futures offer the security of a contract getting executed at a certain date.

The objective is to protect the interests of the initiator of the contract while speculating the direction of the prices. Accordingly, the buyer and seller can enter into a contract depending on the risk-taking ability and trust in their intuition. Since futures involves the presence of an exchange, the execution of the contract is likely, whereas options do not have such an option but on the payment of a premium amount, one can lock in the contract and depend on where the direction of prices are towards the end of the duration, the contract can either be executed or allow expiring worthless.

This has been a guide to Futures vs Options. Here we discuss the differences and similarities between the two with infographics and comparison table. You may also have a look at the following articles to learn more –

Trading Options on Futures Contracts: Tips With Selling Short

Glenn Stok writes about investment strategies and controlling risk that he has perfected with 45 years trading stocks, options, and futures.

Knowledge of put and call options, as well as knowing what trading long and short means, is a vital prerequisite to get the most out of this article.

Best Binary Options Brokers 2020:
  • Binarium
    Binarium

    The Best Binary Options Broker 2020!
    Perfect Choice For Beginners!
    Free Demo Account!
    Free Trading Education!
    Get Your Sing-Up Bonus Now!

  • Binomo
    Binomo

    Only For Experienced Traders!

When you sell options short on stocks or futures, the odds are in your favor. That’s because options lose value as they reach expiration due to time decay.

When you sell short 1 , you can buy options back at a lower price and keep the difference as a profit or let them expire and keep 100% of the funds received, less the commission.

Most traders only think of buying options (going long). They lose most of the time. The person buying options needs to be right with his or her assumption of the direction the underlying instrument will take.

When you sell short, time decay is your friend. Even if you’re wrong, you can still make a profit if the stock or future doesn’t move too far in the wrong direction.

I’ll give you some tips for successfully trading options on futures. 2

Sell Premium on S&P Futures When Volatility Is High

Selling options is known as selling premium, but you want that premium to be as high as possible, so you increase the chances of it eroding in value quickly. Remember that term, Time Decay?

In order to know that you are getting a decent premium, the best indicator is the volatility. Every commodity has a different volatility indicator.

For example, I sell premium on the E-mini S&P Futures options. I keep an eye on the VIX. That’s the implied volatility of the S&P 500 index options.

The Chicago Board Options Exchange (CBOE) calculates the VIX on a continuous bases while the futures are trading.

When the VIX is historically low, I wouldn’t think of selling short. However, when I see an opportunity because the S&P suddenly shot up or down, I check the VIX. If it also moved up, I might consider selling a put or a call option, depending on which way the market moved.

When you expect the market (or commodity) to go up, sell a put. That means you’re long the market. A put option will lose value when the market goes up. It will also lose value if the market doesn’t move at all. That’s due to the incredible time decay again.

Reversely, if you expect the market to drop, sell a call. That means you’re short the market. A call option will lose value when the market goes down or stays the same.

Define Your Risk to Limit Losses

When you buy a stock, you risk all the money you invested. With options, you have more control over your risk, as long as you include the following method with all your trades. (This works for stock options as well as options on futures).

I’ll explain it with an insurance analogy. You sell short, and you buy insurance to lock yourself into a max loss. The insurance is actually an out-of-the-money option that you buy real cheap.

Here’s a simple example to show how this works:

In the last section, I spoke about selling either a put or a call. Remember, when you sell short, you collect the premium for that sale. That is also known as selling naked.You’re not protected if things go wrong, as I’ll explain.

If it loses value, which is what you want, you can buy it back at the lower price and keep the difference as your profit. In some cases, you may just let it expire worthless, and you keep everything (less commission from the initial sale).

However, if the underlying future commodity does not go the way you thought it would, the option can grow in value. If that happens, you can lose on that trade because you would have to buy it back at a higher price.

The difference is a loss in that case. Time decay may help a little, but only if it doesn’t move to extremes. If things really get bad, that option can grow tremendously, and you can lose a lot.

However, here’s where defining your risk becomes beneficial. If you buy another option way out of the money at the same time when you sell short, you lock yourself into a fixed max loss.

Here’s a quick example without getting into particulars, and ignoring commissions:

Say the S&P is trading at 2100. You think it won’t go below 2000 in the next 30 days.

You sell a put option to expire in 30 days at a strike of 2000 and receive a premium of $8. Each E-mini S&P option is for 1 S&P contract, and each contract has a $50 multiplier, so you receive $400. (The multiplier defines the actual value of each futures contract, known as the notional value).

At the same time, you buy a put option at a strike of 1900, and you pay $2.90 (option price) multiplied by the $50 S&P multiplier, which is $145.

Therefore, you receive $400 less $145, or $255 for the trade. Sure, you get less than the full $400, but that long option locks you into a defined risk of $5,000.

How did I arrive at that risk figure? You sold an option at a strike of 2000 and bought one at a strike of 1900. That’s a 100-point difference, also known as the spread. Multiply that by $50 (the S&P multiplier). 100 x 50 = $5,000.

Actually, your true risk is even lower. It’s $4,745. That’s because you received $255 for the trade ($5,000 – $255 = $4,745).

If you didn’t buy that long option and the market kept going the wrong way, you could lose endlessly, up to infinity. Of course, your broker would give you a margin call and pull you out before that happens, but at a tremendous loss, nevertheless.

When you define your risk, you’ll never get a margin call. No matter how bad things get, you can’t lose more than the amount you defined as your risk – $5,000 in this example.

You can make that risk larger or smaller, depending on your risk tolerance, simply by making the spread larger or smaller.

In case you’re wondering what the percentage gain is, if the option expires worthless, divide the amount you received ($255) by the risk ($5,000). That’s a 5% profit in 30 days. Keep repeating that, and you’re making 60% per year on a $5,000 investment. However, I don’t recommend being greedy.

Take Profits Early

Greed is our enemy. Many people hope to keep all the money by waiting and letting the trade expire worthless because options tend to lose value over time, due to time decay.

They think they are saving the commission since they don’t have to buy it back. However, this strategy is impractical for two reasons:

First: Markets and commodities can turn around any time and move quickly in the wrong direction. Therefore it works best to take profits when you have a 50% gain on the options trade. There is no need to wait for expiration. A gain can be lost if the market turns on you.

Of course, you can always roll down. But rolling takes extra resources, and you might just be priced out of the market if you need to keep rolling month after month.

That’s why you should close the trade when you have a 50% gain.

Second: The second reason why waiting for expiration is impractical is that you are tying up your money for the entire time of the trade. If you already have a 50% profit within a month, take it.

That will also free up your resources so you can enter a new trade when the opportunity presents itself. You might find yourself repeating several trades in a month to make much more without using extra resources. Isn’t that better than waiting for that single trade to expire?

There you have it. Remember to use your due diligence when you enter a trade. Never be greedy and take your profits early. That’s the best strategy.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Futures Contracts

Futures trade like stocks, but you own part of the company when you buy shares of stock. The difference is that futures are contracts for a future sale or purchase. You are committed to buy or sell the commodity that the contract relates to at a later date at a specific price.

One of the best things about trading options on futures is that IRS Section 1256 allows you to report 60% of the gains as Long Term. That is true, no matter how short a time you held the trade. It’s true for futures as well as the options on futures. With stocks, you need to hold over a year for that tax advantage.

Another advantage is that futures only require a small amount to hold the contract. That gives you leverage, but leverage can work against you fast when the price of the future goes against you. That’s why selling options helps, since the options decay as time goes on.

Nevertheless, you need to keep a close eye on things. If you let it go too far in the wrong direction, you would end up having to repurchase the options at a higher price or take delivery on the futures commodity. You wouldn’t want to do either. So as you can see, that’s one of the disadvantages.

As long as you learn to get out quickly when you’re wrong, this type of activity can be quite fruitful.

Now that I covered the most crucial factor to understand, I’ll continue with a list of pros and cons:

Pro: You can buy or sell those futures contracts as easily as trading stocks.

Con: You tie up margin while holding the futures contract, no matter if you buy long or sell short.

Pro: You have leverage. The margin is nowhere near the actual value of the commodity. That’s called the Notional Value. The definition is beyond the scope of this article, but I’ll say it in a few words: It’s the market value times the leverage.

Con: Remember that you are dealing with a contract. If the trade goes against you and you don’t buy back the option to close the trade, then you may end up having to pay the full price of the underlying commodity upon expiration.

Pro: There are no day-trading limits with futures. The IRS will consider you a day trader if you trade stocks more than three times each day. That does not apply to futures contracts, so you can take quick profits with small intraday swings and get right back in again. Doing this with stocks can sometimes cause “Wash Sale Penalties.” But not with futures.

Con: Futures pricing is recorded as Marked to Market. That means you have to pay tax on the gains even if you hold a contract into the next year.

Pro: Futures trade nearly 24 hours a day. They only pause on weekends and a few minutes at the end of each day for exchange record keeping.

Pro: Most Futures Options can’t be exercised before expiration. That’s known as European Style trading. There are some exceptions. American Style can be exercised anytime, as is the case with most stocks.

Which approach do you think is best suited for you?

References

This article is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge. Content is for informational or entertainment purposes only and does not substitute for personal counsel or professional advice in business, financial, legal, or technical matters.

Questions & Answers

I trade ES. What is the best way to protect my account balance from flash crashes?

As with any trade, put a protective stop order on it. Make sure it’s GTC.

I always choose the max loss I’m willing to risk, and I put a stop at that price. Don’t make it too close or you will be stopped out prematurely.

You can even use a trailing stop so your profit growth is locked in as the price rises.

If your broker doesn’t support stop orders on Futures, get another broker.

Profitable Stock Option Trading With the ThinkOrSwim Platform

by Glenn Stok 2

How to Trade Options

by John Coviello 6

10 Factors to Consider When Selecting a Stock

by C. Whitaker 22

Trading Options: TD Ameritrade Options Quiz One of Six

by Chris Andrews 6

This Is How to Get More Bang From Your Buck in the Stock Market

by Daniel Mollat 0

How to Start Investing in the Stock Market With Only $20

How to Read Stock Market Charts

Why Do People Invest in American Eagle Silver Coins?

by John R Wilsdon 10

Comments

Glenn Stok

17 months ago from Long Island, NY

Mike – Selling covered calls on a long position is another strategy you can use. But if the underlying stock or future goes way down, you will lose much more than the money you’d make on the premium from selling the covered call. So you need to consider that, as you alluded to in your comment.

The method I described in this article locks you in to a fixed max loss, therefore defining your risk as I explained.

Mike

What you think of doing covered call writing ( LONG futures + Short ATM or OTM call)

If it works great return on margin money applied due to ES own internal leverage

BUT if ES goes down the losses are multiplied!

Glenn Stok

3 years ago from Long Island, NY

chefsref – What you just described is exactly what I was talking about. Your emotions get in the way and cause you to make mistakes. I personally don’t like mutual funds because they take out fees if they succeed for fail. I can’t give you advice since I’m not a licensed broker, so if that’s working for you, stick to it.

Lee Raynor

3 years ago from Citra Florida

One thing I never see mentioned in trading advice is emotions. I could trade on paper and be fairly successful but put money on the line and it becomes diffficult to stay disciplined and I make errors. Thus I stay away and merely buy mutual funds.

Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages ® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.

HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.

Personal Finance

Connect with us

About Us

Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.

In frictionless market futures contract could be sold

This preview shows page 26 – 31 out of 108 pages.

You’ve reached the end of your free preview.

Want to read all 108 pages?

  • TERM Spring ’12
  • PROFESSOR R.E.Bailey
  • TAGS Economics, oil futures
Share this link with a friend:

Students who viewed this also studied

  • topic09_detailed_note
  • Uni. Essex
  • EC 372 – Spring 2020
  • topic09_note
  • Uni. Essex
  • EC 372 – Spring 2020
  • Incentive for creating ABSs direct and indirect gain I Multi layered products
  • Uni. Essex
  • EC 372 – Spring 2020
  • Firms investment opportunities Each firm chooses between high H and low L
  • Uni. Essex
  • EC 372 – Spring 2020
  • mc_test_11
  • Uni. Essex
  • EC 372 – Spring 2020
  • I Choose N M B such that 1 Zero initial outlay cM 80 N B 2 Zero payoff in each
  • Uni. Essex
  • EC 372 – Spring 2020

Study on the go

  • With market frictions transaction costs it may be profitable to exercise the
  • Essex County College
  • FINANCE 101 – Fall 2020
  • Hedging with stock index futures FTSE 100 index hedging continued I What
  • Uni. Essex
  • EC 372 – Spring 2020
  • Let c and C denote todays premiums prices for European and American style call
  • Uni. Essex
  • EC 372 – Spring 2020
  • D Party A lends cash to B who agrees to purchase an asset with the cash In
  • Uni. Essex
  • EC 372 – Spring 2020
  • I Cornering the market I An investor buys a large proportion of futures
  • Uni. Essex
  • EC 372 – Spring 2020
  • Let us see this with an example given in Table Transaction Costs Associated
  • Birla Institute of Technology & Science, Pilani – Hyderabad
  • ANCE FIN – Spring 2020

What students are saying

As a current student on this bumpy collegiate pathway, I stumbled upon Course Hero, where I can find study resources for nearly all my courses, get online help from tutors 24/7, and even share my old projects, papers, and lecture notes with other students.

Kiran Temple University Fox School of Business ‘17, Course Hero Intern

I cannot even describe how much Course Hero helped me this summer. It’s truly become something I can always rely on and help me. In the end, I was not only able to survive summer classes, but I was able to thrive thanks to Course Hero.

Dana University of Pennsylvania ‘17, Course Hero Intern

The ability to access any university’s resources through Course Hero proved invaluable in my case. I was behind on Tulane coursework and actually used UCLA’s materials to help me move forward and get everything together on time.

Jill Tulane University ‘16, Course Hero Intern

Synthetic Long & Arbitrage

6.1 – Background

Imagine a situation where you would be required to simultaneously establish a long and short position on Nifty Futures, expiring in the same series. How would you do this and more importantly why would you do this?

We will address both these questions in this chapter. To begin with let us understand how this can be done and later move ahead to understand why one would want to do this (if you are curious, arbitrage is the obvious answer).

Options as you may have realized by now, are highly versatile derivative instruments; you can use these instruments to create any kind of payoff structure including that of the futures (both long and short futures payoff).

In this chapter we will understand how we can artificially replicate a long futures pay off using options. However before we proceed, you may want to just review the long Future’s ‘linear’ payoff here

Alternatively, here is a quick overview –

As you can see, the long futures position has been initiated at 2360, and at that point you neither make money nor lose money, hence the point at which you initiate the position becomes the breakeven point. You make a profit as the futures move higher than the breakeven point and you make a loss the lower the futures move below the breakeven point. The amount of profit you make for a 10 point up move is exactly the same as the amount of loss you’d make for a 10 point down move. Because of this linearity in payoff, the future is also called a linear instrument.

The idea with a Synthetic Long is to build a similar long Future’s payoff using options.

6.2 – Strategy Notes

Executing a Synthetic Long is fairly simple; all that one has to do is –

  1. Buy the ATM Call Option
  2. Sell the ATM Put Option

When you do this, you need to make sure –

  1. The options belong to the same underlying
  2. Belongs to the same expiry

Let us take an example to understand this better. Assume Nifty is at 7389, which would make 7400 the ATM strike. Synthetic Long would require us to go long on 7400 CE, the premium for this is Rs.107 and we would short the 7400 PE at 80.

The net cash outflow would be the difference between the two premiums i.e 107 – 80 = 27.

Let us consider a few market expiry scenarios –

Scenario 1 – Market expires at 7200 (below ATM)

At 7200, the 7400 CE would expire worthless, hence we would lose the premium paid i.e Rs.107/-. However the 7400 PE would have an intrinsic value, which can be calculated as follows –

Intrinsic value of Put Option = Max [Strike-Spot, 0]

= Max [7400 – 7200, 0]

Clearly, since we are short on this option, we would lose money from the premium we have received. The loss would be –

Total payoff from the long Call and short Put position would be –

Scenario 2 – Market expires at 7400 (At ATM)

If the market expires exactly at 7400, both the options would expire worthless and hence –

  1. We lose the premium paid for the 7400 CE option i.e 107
  2. We get the retain the premium for the 7400 PE option i.e 80
  3. Net payoff from both the positions would be -27e 80 – 107

Do note, 27 also happens to be the net cash outflow of the strategy, which is also the difference between the two premiums

Scenario 3 – Market expires at 7427 (ATM + Difference between the two premiums)

7427 is an interesting level, this is the breakeven point for the strategy, where we neither make money nor lose money.

  1. 7400 CE – the option is ITM and has an intrinsic value of 27. However we have paid 107 as premium hence we experience a total loss of 80
  2. 7400 PE – the option would expire OTM, hence we get to retain the entire premium of 80.
  3. On one hand we make 80 and the other we lose 80. Hence we neither make nor lose any money, making 7427 the breakeven point for this strategy.

Scenario 4 – Market expires at 7600 (above ATM)

At 7600, the 7400 CE would have an intrinsic value of 200, we would make –

Intrinsic value – Premium

The 7400 PE would expire worthless; hence we get to retain the entire premium of Rs.80.

Total payoff from the strategy would be –

With the above 4 scenarios, we can conclude that the strategy makes money while the market moves higher and loses money while the market goes lower, similar to futures. However this still does not necessarily mean that the payoff is similar to that of futures. To establish that the synthetic long payoff behaves similar to futures, we need evaluate the payoff of the strategy with reference to the breakeven point; let’s say 200 point above and below the breakeven point. If the payoff is identical, then clearly there is linearity in the payoff, similar to futures.

So let’s figure this out.

We know the breakeven point for this is –

ATM + difference between the premiums

= 7427

The payoff around this point should be symmetric. We will consider 7427 + 200 = 7627 and 7427-200 = 7227 for this.

  1. The 7400 CE would have an intrinsic value of 227, hence we get to make 227 – 107 = 120
  2. The 7400 PE would expire worthless, hence we get to keep the entire premium of 80
  3. In all we experience a payoff of 120 + 80 = 200
  1. The 7400 CE would not have any intrinsic value, hence we lose the entire premium paid i.e 107
  2. The 7400 PE would have an intrinsic value of 7400 – 7227 = 173, since we have received 80 as premium the net loss would be 80 – 173 = -93.
  3. In all we experience a payoff of -93-107 = -200

Clearly, there is payoff symmetry around the breakeven, and for this reason, the Synthetic Long mimics the payoff of the long futures instrument.

Further, here is the payoff at various expiry levels –

And when you plot the Net Payoff, we get the payoff structure which is similar to the long call futures.

Having figured out how to set up a Synthetic long, we need to figure out the typical circumstances under which setting up a synthetic long is required.

6.3 – The Fish market Arbitrage

I’ll assume that you have a basic understanding on Arbitrage. In easy words, arbitrage is an opportunity to buy goods/asset in a cheaper market and sell the same in expensive markets and pocket the difference in prices. If executed well, arbitrage trades are almost risk free. Let me attempt to give you a simple example of an arbitrage opportunity.

Assume you live by a coastal city with abundant supply of fresh sea fish, hence the rate at which fish is sold in your city is very low, let’s say Rs.100 per Kg. The neighboring city which is 125 kms away has a huge demand for the same fresh sea fish. However, in this neighboring city the same fish is sold at Rs.150 per Kg.

Given this if you can manage to buy the fish from your city at Rs.100 and manage to sell the same in the neighboring city at Rs.150, then in process you clearly get to pocket the price differential i.e Rs.50. Maybe you will have to account for transportation and other logistics, and instead of Rs.50, you get to keep Rs.30/- per Kg. This is still a beautiful deal and this is a typical arbitrage in the fish market!

It looks perfect, think about it – if you can do this everyday i.e buy fish from your city at Rs.100 and sell in the neighboring city at Rs.150, adjust Rs.20 towards expenses then Rs.30 per KG is guaranteed risk free profit.

This is indeed risk free, provides nothing changes. But if things change, so will your profitability, let me list few things that could change –

  1. No Fish (opportunity risk) – Assume one day you go to the market to buy fish at Rs.100, and you realize there is no fish in the market. Then you have no opportunity to make Rs.30/-.
  2. No Buyers (liquidity risk) – You buy the fish at Rs.100 and go to the neighboring town to sell the same at Rs.150, but you realize that there are no buyers. You are left holding a bag full of dead fish, literally worthless!
  3. Bad bargaining (execution risk) – The entire arbitrage opportunity hinges upon the fact that you can ‘always’ bargain to buy at Rs.100 and sell at Rs.150. What if on a bad day you happen to buy at 110 and sell at 140? You still have to pay 20 for transport, this means instead of the regular 30 Rupees profit you get to make only 10 Rupees, and if this continues, then the arbitrage opportunity would become less attractive and you may not want to do this at all.
  4. Transport becomes expensive (cost of transaction) – This is another crucial factor for the profitability of the arbitrage trade. Imagine if the cost of transportation increases from Rs.20 to Rs.30? Clearly the arbitrage opportunity starts looking less attractive as the cost of execution goes higher and higher. Cost of transaction is a critical factor that makes or breaks an arbitrage opportunity
  5. Competitionkicks in(who can drop lower?) – Given that the world is inherently competitive you are likely to attract some competition who would also like to make that risk free Rs.30. Now imagine this –
    1. So far you are the only one doing this trade i.e buy fish at Rs.100 and sell at Rs.150
    2. Your friend notices you are making a risk free profit, and he now wants to copy you. You can’t really prevent his as this is a free market.
    3. Both of you buy at Rs.100, transport it at Rs.20, and attempt to sell it in the neighboring town
    4. A potential buyer walks in, sees there is a new seller, selling the same quality of fish. Who between the two of you is likely to sell the fish to the buyer?
    5. Clearly given the fish is of the same quality the buyer will buy it from the one selling the fish at a cheaper rate. Assume you want to acquire the client, and therefore drop the price to Rs.145/-
    6. Next day your friend also drops the price, and offers to sell fish at Rs.140 per KG, and therefore igniting a price war. In the whole process the price keeps dropping and the arbitrage opportunity just evaporates.
    7. How low can the price drop? Obviously it can drop to Rs.120 (cost of buying fish plus transport). Beyond 120, it does not makes sense to run the business
    8. Eventually in a perfectly competitive world, competition kicks in and arbitrage opportunity just ceases to exist. In this case, the cost of fish in neighboring town would drop to Rs.120 or a price point in that vicinity.

I hope the above discussion gave you a quick overview on arbitrage. In fact we can define any arbitrage opportunity in terms of a simple mathematical expression, for example with respect to the fish example, here is the mathematical equation –

[Cost of selling fish in town B – Cost of buying fish in town A] = 20

If there is an imbalance in the above equation, then we essentially have an arbitrage opportunity. In all types of markets – fish market, agri market, currency market, and stock market such arbitrage opportunities exist and they are all governed by simple arithmetic equations.

6.4 – The Options arbitrage

Arbitrage opportunities exist in almost every market, one needs to be a keen observer of the market to spot it and profit from it. Typically stock market based arbitrage opportunities allow you to lock in a certain profit (small but guaranteed) and carry this profit irrespective of which direction the market moves. For this reason arbitrage trades are quite a favorite with risk intolerant traders.

I would like to discuss a simple arbitrage case here, the roots of which lie in the concept of ‘Put Call Parity’. I will skip discussing the Put Call Parity theory but would instead jump to illustrate one of its applications.

However I’d suggest you watch this beautiful video from Khan Academy to understand the Put Call Parity –

So based on Put Call Parity, here is an arbitrage equation –

Long Synthetic long + Short Futures = 0

You can elaborate this to –

Long ATM Call + Short ATM Put + Short Futures = 0

The equation states that the P&L upon expiry by virtue of holding a long synthetic long and short future should be zero. Why should this position result in a zero P&L, well the answer to this is attributable to the Put Call Parity.

However, if the P&L is a non zero value, then we have an arbitrage opportunity.

Here is an example that will help you understand this well.

On 21 st Jan, Nifty spot was at 7304, and the Nifty Futures was trading at 7316.

The 7300 CE and PE (ATM options) were trading at 79.5 and 73.85 respectively. Do note, all the contracts belong to the January 2020 series.

Going by the arbitrage equation stated above, if one were to execute the trade, the positions would be –

  1. Long 7300 CE @ 79.5
  2. Short 7300 PE @ 73.85
  3. Short Nifty futures @ 7316

Do note, the first two positions together form a long synthetic long. Now as per the arbitrage equation, upon expiry the positions should result in a zero P&L. Let’s evaluate if this holds true.

Scenario 1 – Expiry at 7200

  • The 7300 CE would expire worthless, hence we lose the premium paid i.e 79.5
  • The 7300 PE would have an intrinsic value of 100, but since we are short at 73.85, the net payoff would be 73.85 – 100 = -26.15
  • We are short on futures at 7316, which would result in a profit of 116 points (7316 – 7200)
  • Net payoff would be -79.5 – 26.15 + 116 = +10.35

Clearly, instead of a 0 payoff, we are experiencing a positive non zero P&L.

Scenario 2 – Expiry at 7300

  • The 7300 CE would expire worthless, hence we lose the premium paid i.e 79.5
  • The 7300 PE would expire worthless, hence we get to retain 73.85
  • We are short on futures at 7316, which would result in a profit of 16 points (7316 – 7300)
  • Net payoff would be -79.5 +73.85+16 = +10.35

Scenario 3 – Expiry at 7400

  • The 7300 CE would have an intrinsic value of 100, and therefore the payoff would be 100 – 79.5 = 20.5
  • The 7300 PE would expire worthless, hence we get to retain 73.85
  • We are short on futures at 7316, which would result in loss of 84 points (7316 – 7400)
  • Net payoff would be 20.5 + 73.85 – 84 = +10.35

You could test this across any expiry value (in other words the markets can move in any direction) but you are likely to pocket 10.35 points, upon expiry. I’d like to stress this again; this arbitrage lets you make 10.35, upon expiry.

Here is the payoff structure at different expiry values –

Interesting isn’t it? But what’s the catch you may ask?

One has to account for the cost of execution of this trade and figure out if it still makes sense to take up the trade. Consider this –

  • Brokerage – if you are trading with a traditional broker, then you will be charged on a percentage basis which will eat away your profits. So on one hand you make 10 points, but you may end up paying 8 – 10 points as brokerage. However if you were to do this trade with a discount broker like Zerodha, your breakeven on this trade would be around 4-5 points. This should give you more reason to open your account with Zerodha ☺
  • STT – Do remember the P&L is realised upon expiry; hence you would have to carry forward your positions to expiry. If you are long on an ITM option (which you will be) then upon expiry you will have to pay a hefty STT, which will further eat away your profits. Please do read this to know more.
  • Other applicable taxes – Besides you also have to account for service tax, stamp duty etc

So considering these costs, the efforts to carry an arbitrage trade for 10 points may not make sense. But it certainly would, if the payoff was something better, maybe like 15 or 20 points. With 15 or 20 points you can even maneuver the STT trap by squaring off the positions just before expiry – although it will shave off a few points.

Best Binary Options Brokers 2020:
  • Binarium
    Binarium

    The Best Binary Options Broker 2020!
    Perfect Choice For Beginners!
    Free Demo Account!
    Free Trading Education!
    Get Your Sing-Up Bonus Now!

  • Binomo
    Binomo

    Only For Experienced Traders!

Like this post? Please share to your friends:
Binary Options Trading For Beginners
Leave a Reply

;-) :| :x :twisted: :smile: :shock: :sad: :roll: :razz: :oops: :o :mrgreen: :lol: :idea: :grin: :evil: :cry: :cool: :arrow: :???: :?: :!: